Independent Panel to Review Police Shootings [VIDEO]
New details emerge about Greenland chief's death.
New Hampshire Attorney General Michael Delaney announced this afternoon that he has formed an independent panel to conduct a comprehensive review into the April 12 shooting that resulted in the death of Greenland Police Chief Michael Maloney and wounded four other Drug Task Force officers.
The five-member review committee will be chaired by retired Nashua Police Chief Donald Conley and will also include Tilton Police Chief Robert Cormier, Belknap County Sheriff Craig Wiggin, retired Hudson Police Capt. William Pease, and retired judge and Portsmouth attorney Steven Roberts.
Delaney said it is important that an independent review be conducted, and he is confident that this committee is "well suited and extensively qualified" to conduct that review.
He said the review committee will conduct a review of the circumstances leading to the decision to execute a search and arrest warrant on April 12, and the manner in which the warrants were executed. The panel will also examine Drug Task Force policies and procedures and report its findings in a written document what will include an assessment of the overall operation and any recommendations "deemed appropriate."
Delaney announced the formation of the review committee at a press conference at his office.
He also spoke of what a difficult month April was for the state and the law enforcement community.
"These events remind us all of the daily sacrifices made by our police officers," Delaney said, calling the incident "a tragic reminder of just how dangerous a job it is."
Maloney and four other officers were attempting to execute a warrant at the home of Cullen Mutrie when Mutrie opened fire on them, killing Maloney and wounding four members of the Attorney General's Drug Task Force. Mutrie later shot and killed his ex-girlfriend, Brittany Tibbetts, before turning the gun on himself.
“What we’re trying to do today is to ensure that in light of what has occurred, we do everything we can to ensure that all of these facts are reviewed comprehensively," Delaney said, "to both learn what was done well under the circumstances and identify any lessons that can be learned.”
After his remarks, Delaney was peppered with questions about the incident but admitted that the investigation was not yet complete. He said investigators wanted to make sure that the injured officers had time to heal from the wounds of the incident.
“I do want to emphasize that we do have an ongoing investigation that is pending,” he said. “Not all of the statements and interviews that we need to complete have been completed.”
Delaney said two uniformed officers approached the porch at the home and attempted to make contact with Mutrie, but were unsuccessful. The officers did not perform a no-knock entry into the home, he said. The Drug Task Force officers reportedly saw no motion and received no response at the the door. Six of them went into the home, and four of them received gunshot wounds, he said.
Maloney was not involved in the initial entry into the home. He arrived at the scene at the time the first officers were sent in, Delaney confirmed. Two uniformed officers and Maloney went in to get the injured officers who were inside the home, he said. Maloney was in a position of cover behind his car, looking at the home, when he was shot in the head and killed, according to Delaney.
Delaney said he believed Mutrie killed Maloney, but was not completely sure. He said he could not speak to the position of shooters inside the home.
University of New Hampshire Police Chief Paul Dean issued a statement Tuesday afternoon following Delaney's press conference, saying that his department is "supportive" of the attorney general's review. UNH Detective Eric Kulberg was one of the officers injured in the shooting.
Dean said once the findings of the review committee have been reported, the UNH Police Department will conduct its own review "based on department policies."
Michael Mickelson
4:02 pm on Tuesday, May 1, 2012
I'm concerned about the lack of bullet proof vests....
Gail Lynch
4:27 pm on Tuesday, May 1, 2012
We can see more of these incidents more often. The gun laws in this state are loosey goosey. New Hampshire should change it's name to New Hampshabama. Steroids and guns don't mix. This guy was a known drug dealer, obviously testing more of the stuff than selling it, and he had guns? We can buy all of the bullet proof vests all you want, but what about helmets? The yahoos in the state house need to get their priorities straight. Wake the hell up and drink the coffee already.
Big Ben
4:57 pm on Tuesday, May 1, 2012
Welcome to the US of NRA! It's this way in every state.
Concerned Man
10:22 pm on Tuesday, May 1, 2012
It is heart breaking that anyone is killed, by a gun or otherwise. Unfortunately, we have a culture & society of violence that is propagated by the media, saturating the public's consciousness with fear and anger.
I think there are many factors in this particular case that do not have to happen again. If this man had been disturbing the peace in his community repeatedly, been arrested repeatedly and violated the law, again and again without regret, then the system has failed to uphold it's duty. Furthermore, the police have options and don't necessarily have to serve a warrant at the suspect's house. Every situation has a possibility for violence but ought to be minimized at every step.
People with no regard for the law, or for other human beings, don't abide by gun laws (or any law). This is why they are criminals. If police and criminals are the only people with guns, then the police will be heavily out-gunned.
Article 2-a of the New Hampshire Constitution says we have the right to bear arms. It is also the 2nd Amendment in the Bill of Rights to the U.S. Constitution. The people have the right to protect themselves against harm by criminals or rogue agents or factions of government.
To greatly reduce similar events, an in-depth review and analysis of the law and enforcement are in order.
Condolences to the families and friends of all deceased parties involved. May people get the help they need, and may those who serve be safe from harm.
Kurt Hamilton
5:00 pm on Tuesday, May 1, 2012
I'm glad the top people are approaching this in a very professional way. To see what can be done differently to save lives.
Andre
7:01 pm on Tuesday, May 1, 2012
where in the article does it state the officers were not wearing ballistic vests????
Ariane Train
7:38 pm on Tuesday, May 1, 2012
Glad to hear that an "independent" panel has been created to review this! I am tired of hearing about only one victim - we are forgetting that another beautiful girl (who is innocent until proven guilty) is also dead. Brittany did not have to die!!
Seamus Carty
9:08 am on Thursday, May 3, 2012
Innocent until proven guilty would apply in a trial, but there will not be one. She had to know that this guy was a criminal. No job but lots of money. People coming to the house to buy drugs. Come on...
Liz
8:56 pm on Tuesday, May 1, 2012
FYI they were all wearing bullet proof vests. Injuries that were sustained were (2) arm injuries, head wound and (2) chest wounds that went under the vest. Bullet proof vests are wonderful, but do not protect against all ammunition/bullets can go under (generally near armpit area or on the side of the body).